Being the mum I should be…

Lily Allen is at it again. Spouting in an interview about how boring it is to be a stay at home mum and that it doesn’t allow any outlet for her creativity.

Being the mum I should be

About a year ago, I was spitting feathers after reading some similar comments by her in Glamour magazine. Something about never being the kind of person who could sit at home all day playing with plastic toys and watching Peppa Pig (as if that is all a stay at home mum does with her day!). At the time, the comment made me want to throw my phone across the room.

The thing is, you see, I am a stay at home mum. A happy stay at home mum who made a conscious decision to quit her job. An intelligent stay at home mum who has to admit it really rankles when it is implied that being out of the workplace makes her less fulfilled, less interesting, less of a thinking/being person. That she is somehow leading a blander life than her working mum counterparts.

Having pondered the issue many times over the last couple of years, however, I have come to realise a few things:

  1. Our society/media seems to continually try to polarise women and the choices we make. The stay at home mum vs working mum debate is just one example. You are either a boring, no life stay at home mum or the fulfilled, do it all working mum. Or, on the flipside, the nurturing, caring, completely dedicated to her offspring’s needs every minute of the day stay at home mum vs the burnt out, selfish, guilt-infested wreck of a working mum. These are, of course, ridiculous one-dimensional representations and an insult to all mums, whatever they choose (or have) to do.
  2. While the media will often pit women against each other, we are pretty good at doing it all by ourselves. I notice this more than ever now I am a parent. Every choice we make as a mum on how we will raise our children is fair game – the type of birth you have, whether you breastfeed, how you wean, whether you sleep train, how you potty train, how you handle your child’s behaviour, and, yes, whether you go back to work or stay at home. Sadly, it is mostly women doing the judging. Is this is a defensive reaction (she’s doing it differently to me; this must imply a criticism of my parenting techniques), a way of justifying our own choices (as I think nearly all mums question themselves at least some of the time!) or simply how we are programmed by our society to behave with each other? Or perhaps a combination of all three.
  3. As a stay at home mum, I can admit that I am probably a wee bit defensive about perceived slights on what I do. How many conversations have I had with a working mum who says something like: “I do love being back at work, it makes me feel like I am using my brain again.” While I am sitting there, smiling politely but bristling inside, thinking: “Er, excuse me, does that mean that I don’t use my brain?!” Maybe some of these people did intend a barb at my expense but I’m willing to believe that most didn’t even realise I would take their comments that way. The Lily Allen interviews are another example: she’s just talking about why she wanted to go back to work. The airy dismissal of everything I do all day may be there or, equally, I could be honing in on those sentences as they are the ones that resonate personally.
  4. Either way, it ACTUALLY DOESN’T MATTER. Yes, there are without a doubt many high profile or otherwise women who will put the stay at home mum down for whatever reason. Just as there are smug stay at home mothers who make anyone who dares return to work and enjoy it feel hugely selfish and uncaring of their children’s needs. It would be great if this didn’t happen, if we could all stop and think for a second before judging fellow mums. Wouldn’t that make for a much nicer world? Unfortunately it does happen, but here is a little secret that I am just beginning to learn: we can ignore it. We can look to our own lives and the decisions we make and realise that, as long as we are happy with what we are doing, it doesn’t actually matter what anybody else says about it.

Of course, the last point is easier said than done… I would say I am a work in progress as the Lily Allen comments clearly still hit a nerve, yet within a few minutes I was able to laugh it off.

Whatever choices you make as a mum, there will always be a little voice inside your head doubting or casting guilt. My mission for 2014 is to feel confident in the decisions I make and the reasons for making them. If I am not, why not? Should I be making a different choice? Because if I am truly happy with what I am doing (and it works for us as a family) then I am being the mum I should be and that is the only important thing I need to focus on.

You might also like:


9 Comments on “Being the mum I should be…”

  1. […] Cuddles & Muddles & Muddy Puddles […]

  2. Great post! I agree completely! I have enjoyed reading your blog and nominated you for a Liebster Award. :) Here is the link to my post with your nomination:
    Thanks for being a great blogger.

  3. sparrow says:

    What a great post!! Thank you!! I have been thinking about this issue a lot, trying not to feel insecure and instead listen to myself and what feels right for my life. I’ve been home with my babies for eight months now and having angst about it, not helped by perceived judgement from family, friends, or whatever attitudes I’ve picked up elsewhere. Everyone is different, each family is different, and we have to make decisions in the real world, not based on what some perfect Mother might do.

    • Thank you :) Yes, isn’t it so tough to feel confident in the decisions you make as a mum – there are too many areas where we can feel judged and doubt ourselves. But I definitely found the first year the hardest. I’m not an expert now by any means but I’m starting to shut out the other ‘noise’ and learn to trust my instincts more. Hopefully that will continue!

  4. Great post! I tend to veer towards the ‘it doesn’t matter what you think’ world, as it’s my choice, my kids, and I know what we do each day #MBPW

  5. Brilliant post. You explain the problems with this competitive motherhood business so eloquently. I just don’t understand why it happens, but it does, all the time. We respect each other’s choices in the jobs we do, houses we live in, clothes we wear; so why as soon as motherhood happens do we no longer think it’s okay to be different? Drives me potty! It is hard not to let other people’s comments or perceived barbs get to you though, I have done it myself. I guess because motherhood is so important and something we don’t want to get ‘wrong’ the things other people say make us question our actions.

    • Thank you :) Yes, I find it so strange how parenting invites judgement and comparison like no other area of our lives. As you say, probably because it’s so important and all-encompassing, it’s easy to take everything very personally. I wish we could all just be confident and generous enough to recognise we all do motherhood differently – and that’s ok :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s